Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes

I am a mashed potato lover. So much so that when Mike and I travel, if we’re staying somewhere with a kitchen, I almost always buy local potatoes and make mash.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

  • Done days ahead: stress free perfect potatoes and your stove and oven are free on the big day.
  • Even better reheated: gently rewarmed with butter and half and half, they come back creamier and more potato flavored.
  • Emergency potatoes: they hold so well you can make way more than you need in case someone is extra hungry.

At a glance

Recipe micro facts
Flavor Profile Rich, buttery and extra potatoey with a silky-smooth texture.
Make Ahead Tips Make them up to 4 days ahead and keep them in the fridge, or freeze them for up to 1 month.
Storage Refrigerate in an airtight container for up to 4 days. Freeze for up to 1 month and thaw overnight in the fridge.
Reheating Reheat until hot and steamy (165°F)
Difficulty Easy
Pro-trick Sieve or rice the potatoes while they’re hot. Potatoes that have cooled down turn gluey.

It’s such a fun way to experience a different country. In Iceland I discovered my love of Icelandic butter, in Hokkaido I agreed that their potatoes are elite, and I am proud to say that I’ve eaten mashed potatoes on almost all the continents. Can you guess which two we haven’t been to?

Anyway, I know potatoes. Just ask Mike, who once made me a double blind taste test of mashed potatoes with a regular conventional potato and an extra special organic variety he found at Whole Foods. He was amazed that I could tell the difference. To be honest I was amazed too, but really, potatoes are my special interest, so I shouldn’t have been.

I like my mash smooth and creamy, no big lumps please. It’s not like rustic, lumpy mashed potatoes aren’t good, it’s just that smooth mashed potatoes are just so much better. For me, the perfect mash is smooth and creamy, not gluey, not waxy, and not dry. It tastes amazing on its own and even better when served alongside a delicious roast meat.

Overhead of make-ahead mashed potatoes topped with butter and chives, with extra butter and chives around the bowl

Why make mashed potatoes ahead

One of the best things about mashed potatoes is that you can make them ahead of time, which takes the pressure off while you’re entertaining, letting you be nice and relaxed on the big day. Not only do they hold just fine, I think making them ahead actually improves their texture. I always make mine in advance if I planned ahead enough. When the potatoes are in the fridge, the starches firm up and then relax when they’re reheated gently, giving the potatoes a creamy, smooth consistency. It’s a huge time saver and you end up with a more consistent, evenly flavored, rich and delicious mash.

Think about it: your favorite steakhouse isn’t mashing potatoes a la minute. They’re portioning out already cooked mashed potatoes and reheating them with milk, cream, or half and half, with butter.

The slow part, pushing everything through a sieve, happens days before anyone shows up, and your stove and oven are free on the day for the turkey, the gravy and the rolls.

And since they hold so well, you can make way more than you need, so you always have emergency potatoes in case someone is extra hungry.

How to choose the right potatoes for mash

Yukon Gold are my gold standard for mashed potatoes, but did you know that a lot of stores don’t carry Yukon Golds anymore? Apparently, they’re one of those finicky crops that farmers hate because the yield is so annoyingly low and they get sick easily. If you go to the store, you’ll most likely see generic yellow potatoes, which aren’t quite the same as Yukon Golds.

Regular yellow flesh potatoes are usually waxier than Yukon Golds so I like to do a mix of yellow potatoes and russets. The yellow potatoes give you that pleasing golden color and creaminess and the russets are fluffy and potatoey. The resulting mash won’t be as yellow as mash made with all yellow potatoes, and we eat with our eyes first, so if you want to trick everyone into thinking that your potatoes are extra buttery, go for an all yellow potato mash, but it’ll be a little less fluffy.

Whole unpeeled russet and yellow potatoes in a white Dutch oven

Make ahead mashed potatoes

Make ahead mashed potatoes are incredibly easy to make. I mean, it’s the same as making regular mashed potatoes. The secret in make ahead is how you reheat. You can make them 3-4 days in advance or even freeze them for up to a month. Here’s how I like making my mash, either for eating right away or for reheating.

Scrub

Scrub your potatoes thoroughly. I like to keep my potatoes whole while cooking as the potato skins keep the potatoes from getting waterlogged. Waterlogged potatoes are no good.

Simmer

Place the clean potatoes in a very large pot and cover with at least 2 inches of cold water. Heavily salt the water and bring the whole thing up to a boil over high heat, then, when at a rapid boil, turn the heat to medium, so that you’re at a simmer, but not a rolling boil. Starting cold and simmering gently cooks them evenly; a rolling boil cooks the outsides before the insides. Once you’re at the simmer stage, it takes about 30-40 minutes to cook the potatoes thoroughly, depending on size. Top up the water if the potatoes start poking out. Use a cake tester, skewer, or butter knife to check the biggest potato. You want them to be very soft and evenly cooked through.

Peel

Once the potatoes are completely cooked, transfer them carefully to a cutting board and peel while hot, holding each one with a fork and scraping with a butter knife. The skins will just slide right off. Pour the water out of the pot you cooked the potatoes in, making sure it’s completely dry.

Boiled potatoes peeled on a wooden board, skins scraped off beside a fork, knife and tongs

Mash

This is the part where everyone has the method they swear by. I really think it’s up to you and what style of potato you like. For me, I like running all my mash through a fine mesh sieve. I tried using a ricer because everyone says riced potatoes are the fluffiest, but I didn’t and I couldn’t take it. I ended up pushing the potatoes through a sieve afterwards because they weren’t up to my smoothness standard. Yes, it takes a long time, but it’s worth it. I’m going to go out on a limb here and say you NEED to push your hot cooked potatoes through a fine mesh sieve using a wooden spoon. Do this over the dry pot that you cooked the potatoes in.

Stir

Once your potatoes are mashed, add the butter to the hot potatoes. Or even better, rice or sieve the hot potatoes right on top of the butter so the residual heat of the pot and the potatoes gently melt the butter. Once the butter is completely melted, fold into the potatoes. All of this is off the heat. Just let the potatoes rest while you warm up the half and half.

Cream

In a small pot, warm up half and half and cream cheese, whisking until completely smooth. You won’t taste the cream cheese, it will just give the potatoes a nice creamy mouthfeel that will have you wondering, how did these potatoes get so creamy? It’s also what keeps them creamy after a couple of days in the fridge. When the half and half is steamy and the cream cheese is completely smooth and incorporated, pour into the potatoes and fold gently.

Season

Taste and season with salt (and pepper if you like that). Potatoes need salt to taste good, but over salty potatoes are horrible, so start with a bit and incrementally season, bit by bit.

Make-ahead mashed potatoes swirled in a serving bowl, with melted butter and chives on the side

How to save mashed potatoes for later

Now your potatoes are ready, either to enjoy right away or to save for another day. Let them cool, then get them into an airtight container and into the fridge within 2 hours. They’ll keep for up to 3-4 days in the fridge or 1 month in the freezer. If you’re anything like me, after you store the mash, you get to lick the spatula or spoon. Way better than raw cake batter, am I right?

Cold, stiff mashed potatoes straight from the fridge in a stainless steel pot

How to reheat mashed potatoes

To reheat from the freezer: Let the potatoes thaw overnight in the fridge, then proceed with the from the fridge instructions.

To reheat from the fridge: Take the potatoes out of the fridge 30 minutes to 1 hour ahead, and reheat until they’re hot and steamy all the way through using one of the following methods:

Stovetop

Heat up butter and half and half in a large, heavy-bottomed pot over medium low heat. Add the potatoes and stir, until the butter and cream are incorporated. Continue to stir and heat over low until the potatoes are hot and steamy throughout, about 8-10 minutes, depending on stove strength. Be sure to stir often or the bottom layer of mashed potatoes could brown a bit.

Oven

About an hour before serving, heat the oven to 325°F. Lightly butter a casserole dish and spread the potatoes in it. Dot the top of the potatoes with cold cubed butter. Cover the dish tightly with foil and bake until warmed through, about 40-50 minutes. Halfway through, gently stir in the half and half, cover again and heat until completely they’re hot and steamy in the center.

Serve warm, either in the casserole dish, or transferred to a serving dish, topped with additional butter, freshly chopped chives, and freshly ground black pepper, if desired.

Microwave

Put the potatoes in a microwave-safe bowl with the butter and half and half, cover, and heat on high in 2-minute bursts, stirring in between, until hot and steamy throughout, about 8 minutes in ours.

Reheated mash, glossy and creamy again, being stirred with a spatula in a stainless steel pot

Tips and tricks for the best mashed potatoes

Whole, unpeeled potatoes

Most recipes call for peeling potatoes and cutting them into chunks for even cooking and I do this too if I’m making a small batch of mash. But for bigger batches, I don’t know what it is, but I always end up doing something else and when I get back, my potatoes are waterlogged. Waterlogged potatoes are the enemy of a smooth mash. Just don’t peel your potatoes. The peel stops the majority of water from soaking in and your potatoes, as a result, will taste more potato-y. I think medium potatoes are the best size as well, the ones that are the size of a large avocado.

A fine mesh sieve is your best friend

Keep your potato ricers and mashers, I’m team fine mesh sieve all the way. Pushing hot potatoes through a fine mesh sieve will give you the smoothest, creamiest, restaurant style mashed potatoes you’ll ever make. The potatoes are broken down and separated into tiny, tiny individual potato cells along their natural boundaries without crushing them and gets them smooth in one pass. To get a masher anywhere close, you’d have to keep working the potatoes, and overworked potatoes burst their cells and turn gluey.

Pushing them through a sieve instead makes the tiny potato particles happy. They are nice and separate with no sticky starches so they are free to absorb all the warm butter and dairy they want.

Mash being pushed through a fine mesh sieve with a wooden spoon over a stainless steel pot

Tips on pushing potatoes through a fine mesh sieve

There’s a technique to pushing potatoes through a mesh sieve. It’s called hard work. It takes twice as long and infinitely more arm power. There’s no secret, you just need to get a wooden spoon (don’t use a silicone spatula or anything soft because it will drive you nuts) and push the potatoes through. I like to use two pots: one to hold the sieve while I’m pushing the potatoes through and another one to collect the smooth potatoes. You have to use a silicone spatula from time to time scrape the mash off the underside of the sieve otherwise you have a hard time pushing through more potato. Ask me how I know this.

How many potatoes do you need per person for mashed potatoes

The standard is 1/2 lb of potato per person, but when I told Mike this, he said that isn’t enough. I thought I was the potato monster, but apparently he is too? If you want to have leftovers, I would say go for 3/4 lb per person. The recipe card is set at 1/2 lb per person, so be sure scale up for emergency potatoes.

Close-up of mashed potatoes topped with melting butter and chopped chives

Troubleshooting

Too stiff or dry after reheating: stir in warm half and half, a splash at a time, until they’re creamy again.

Too loose: keep stirring over low heat, uncovered, to cook off some of the liquid. In a pinch, stir in a spoonful of instant potato flakes.

Watery: the skins split while they were cooking. Stir the mash in the dry pot over low heat for a minute or two before the butter goes in.

Gluey: they got overworked, or they cooled down before you sieved them. There’s no real fix, but don’t worry, it’ll still be amazing with turkey and gravy and all the trimmings, no need to stress!

Brown on the bottom: the heat was too high. Turn it to low, stir more often, and leave the browned bit behind.

FAQ

Can you freeze mashed potatoes? Yes, for up to 1 month. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then reheat with the butter and half and half.

Can I make them without cream cheese? Use the same amount of sour cream instead. It’ll be a little tangier.

Can I use a ricer? Yes! It won’t be quite as smooth as a sieve, but it’s faster and way easier on your arms.

Riced potatoes in a white Dutch oven

More make-ahead Thanksgiving

All that to say: I love potatoes.

I have many, many stories about me and potatoes and I even have a side hustle where I draw potatoes. Potatoes are truly life and if you don’t love potatoes, you aren’t living. These make ahead mashed potatoes are as easy as can be and taste like you’ve made them on the day of instead of your day off.

xoxo
steph

PS: if you were wondering, the two continents I haven’t had potatoes at are Africa and Antarctica.

Overhead of make-ahead mashed potatoes topped with butter and chives, with extra butter and chives around the bowl


Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes

Your favorite steakhouse isn’t mashing potatoes a la minute, and neither should you.

Serves 8

No ratings yet

Prep Time 10 minutes

Cook Time 1 hour

Total Time 1 hour 10 minutes

Potatoes

  • 2 lbs yellow potatoes
  • 2 lbs russet potatoes
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter
  • 1 1/2 cup half and half
  • 4 ounces cream cheese at room temp

To reheat:

  • 1/4 cup butter
  • 1/2 cup half and half

To serve:

  • 1/4 cup butter
  • chives if desired
  • Scrub the potatoes thoroughly. Add the potatoes to a large Dutch oven or pot. Cover with cold water (the potatoes should have at least 2 inches of water on top) and season the water with 1 tbsp kosher salt.

  • Place the pot over medium-high heat and bring to a boil, then reduce the heat to medium to maintain a simmer. Cook for 30-40 minutes, or until the potatoes are tender and cooked through, adding water to cover the potatoes as needed. Use a paring knife or a cake tester to gently poke at the largest potato to assess. You want there to be zero resistance.

  • Use a pair of tongs to remove the potatoes from the water, placing onto a cutting board.

  • Drain the pot and place back on the stove with the heat off. Carefully peel the potatoes using a fork and a butter knife to scrape away the peels. The peels will fall off easily. Discard the peels and place the potatoes in a large bowl. Continue until all the potatoes are peeled.

  • Push the hot, soft potatoes through a fine mesh sieve back into the pot they were boiled in. If you’re feeling lazy or short on time, use a potato ricer instead.

  • When all the potatoes have been sieved or riced, top with the butter. Let the residual heat of the potatoes gently melt the butter.

  • In a separate small saucepan, add the half and half and cubes of cream cheese. Warm, over medium-low heat, stirring, until the cream cheese is completely melted and the half and half mix is smooth. When warm and steamy, remove from the heat.

  • With a silicone spatula, gently fold the butter, which should now be melted, into the potatoes. When fully incorporated, fold in the warm half and half cream cheese mix.

  • Taste and season with salt and pepper. Start with 1 teaspoon of salt, tasting and adjusting by the 1/4 teaspoon.

  • Let cool and store in the fridge in an airtight container for 3-4 days or in the freezer for up to 1 month.

  • Reheating: If reheating from frozen, let thaw overnight in the fridge. When ready to reheat, bring your potatoes up to room temp before heating by taking the potatoes out of the fridge and tempering for 30 minutes to 1 hour.Stove top: This is the best method of reheating mashed potatoes and what they do in restaurants. Take the mashed potatoes out of the fridge and let come to room temp while you grab a Dutch oven, or other similar heavy-bottomed pot, large enough to fit the potatoes, about 4.5-6 quarts.Add the butter and and half and half to the pot and heat over medium low heat, stirring to help the butter melt. Add the potatoes to the pot, bit by bit, stirring and incorporating the melted butter and half and half. Turn the heat to low and continue to stir occasionally, until the potatoes are hot and steamy throughout, about 8-10 minutes. The potatoes, because they’re thick, have a tendency to sputter, so keep stirring to distribute the heat throughout. When hot and steamy, turn the heat off and give the potatoes a good stir with a silicone spatula, until they look smooth and creamy. Taste, adjust the seasoning if needed, then transfer to a serving dish and enjoy.Oven: An hour before eating, lightly butter the bottoms and sides of a casserole dish. Transfer the potatoes to the buttered dish. Top the potatoes with the butter cut into small cubes. Cover with foil and heat in a low 325°F oven for 40-50 minutes. Halfway through warming, stir in the half and half. Continue to warm, covered, until warmed through. When hot and steamy, give the potatoes a good mix to ensure that they are smooth and creamy. Taste and season, if needed, and enjoy.Microwave: Add the potatoes, butter and half and half to a large microwave-safe bowl. Cover and heat on high in 2-minute bursts, stirring in between, until hot and steamy throughout, about 8 minutes. Best for smaller batches.

Prep time may take longer if you sieve.

Nutrition Facts

Make Ahead Mashed Potatoes

Amount Per Serving

Calories 432 Calories from Fat 261

% Daily Value*

Fat 29g45%

Saturated Fat 18g113%

Cholesterol 81mg27%

Sodium 235mg10%

Potassium 944mg27%

Carbohydrates 38g13%

Fiber 4g17%

Sugar 5g6%

Protein 7g14%

* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2000 calorie diet.